Living in Florida's Space Coast
TORTOISE ISLAND
Tortoise Island is the single-family neighborhood in Satellite Beach where $1,450,000 was the median across 21 closed sales in the last twelve months, 27 of 28 properties front a canal, and the association runs about $355 a month. Built 1979 to 2004.
Tortoise Island In Satellite Beach, Florida
Tortoise Island sits in Satellite Beach, in the 32937 zip code, on Lanternback Island, Loggerhead Island, Hawksbill Island and Tortoise. Over the last twelve months 21 of the 28 properties I tracked here actually closed, at a $1,450,000 median.
The housing stock is 28 single-family homes, built 1979 to 2004. The size range runs 2,317 to 5,439 square feet, which is wide enough that the neighborhood median tells you very little about any one property. Price it off the comparable sales on that street, not the plat.
Sellers closed at about 95 percent of original list, a normal working spread for beachside Brevard. The room that exists shows up on properties that have already cut once.
27 of the 28 properties front a canal, so water is the default here rather than the upgrade. What moves price is the condition of the seawall, the dock and the lift, and none of that shows in the photos.
Tortoise Island At A Glance
Every figure below comes from the last twelve months of Satellite Beach market data for this neighborhood. Nothing here is an estimate.
| Detail | What you get |
|---|---|
| Housing type | 28 single-family homes |
| Home size range | Roughly 2,317 to 5,439 square feet, median about 3,615 |
| Bedrooms and baths | three to five bedrooms, two to six baths |
| Lot size | 0.28 to 0.55 acres, median about 0.34 |
| Year built | 1979 to 2004, median 1989 |
| Median sold price | $1,450,000 over the last twelve months |
| Sold price range | $850,000 to $2,530,000 |
| Price per square foot | About $430 median |
| HOA dues | $355 median a month, reported on 28 of 28 listings |
| Waterfront | 27 of 28, on a canal |
| Private pools | 26 of 28 |
| Garage | 28 of 28 listings reported a garage |
| Property tax | About $9,015 median annual, ranging widely with assessment history |
| Days on market | 21 days median, at about 95 percent of original asking price |
| Location | Satellite Beach, 32937 |
Tortoise Island Costs, Honestly
The line items that decide what this actually costs you, beyond the purchase price.
Insurance And Flood
Get the quote firstEvery address on this island is underwritten on its own elevation certificate, roof age and opening protection. Two properties on the same street can be thousands apart a year. I get you a real quote inside the inspection period, before the payment you are picturing becomes the payment you are stuck with.
The Seawall And The Dock
The item people forgetA seawall has a lifespan and replacing one is a five figure job. So is a dock, a lift and the electrical that runs them. On a property where the association may or may not own that structure, that question gets answered in writing before you go hard on a deposit.
The Tax Bill Resets
About $9,015 median todayThat is what the current owners pay, not what you will. Florida caps annual assessment increases for homesteaded owners and the cap resets on sale, so on a property somebody has held fifteen years your first bill can land materially higher. I run the reset number before you write.
Real Negotiating Room
About 95 percent of original listA 21 day median with closings near 95 percent of the original asking price. That is a narrow gap, so the win here comes from being ready to move rather than from grinding the price.
Tortoise Island Features
Waterfront Is Standard
27 of the 28 properties front a canal. Verify the seawall condition, the dock permit and the actual depth at low tide before you rely on a listing photo.
Association On Record
A median of $355 a month across 28 of the 28 listings. I pull the budget, the reserve study and the last two years of minutes before you go under contract.
Pools Are Standard
26 of the last 28 had a private pool. On the barrier island the pump, the heater and the screen enclosure age faster than they do inland, so those get inspected separately from the house.
A Very Wide Price Range
From $850,000 to $2,530,000 on the same streets, so condition and location inside the plat decide price far more than the address does.
Original Era Housing
Median year built is 1989. Roof age, wiring and plumbing are the three things that decide both your insurance quote and your first five years of budget.
Garages Are Common
28 of the 28 listings reported a garage, which on the beachside is less common than buyers expect.
Homes For Sale In Tortoise Island
Every active Tortoise Island listing, straight from the MLS and updated as it changes.
Tortoise Island Frequently Asked Questions
What do homes sell for in Tortoise Island?
The median closed price over the last twelve months was $1,450,000 across 21 sales, ranging $850,000 to $2,530,000. Median price per square foot was $430.
Does Tortoise Island have an HOA?
Yes. The median reported association fee is $355 a month, on 28 of the 28 listings. What it covers varies, so I read the budget, the reserve study and the assessment history before you go under contract.
Is Tortoise Island waterfront?
27 of the 28 properties front a canal. Which water it is changes the price, and on canal or river frontage the seawall, the dock permit and the low tide depth all need checking before you rely on the photos.
Can you negotiate on price in Tortoise Island?
Sellers closed at about 95 percent of original list over the last year. There is some room, and it tends to show up on properties that have already had a price cut. I price the offer off the specific comparable sales, not the neighborhood average.
Are there pool homes in Tortoise Island?
Yes. 26 of the 28 properties have a private pool. On the barrier island the pump, the heater and the screen enclosure age faster than inland, so I have those inspected separately from the structure.
What are property taxes like in Tortoise Island?
The median bill on record is about $9,015, but that is what the current owners pay. Florida caps annual assessment increases for homesteaded owners and the cap resets when the property sells, so your first bill can be materially higher. I run the reset number before you write an offer.
What is the buying process like in Tortoise Island?
I pull the closed comparable sales for the specific street, get a real wind and flood quote inside the inspection period, run the tax reset so the monthly payment you are picturing is the one you will actually have, and read whatever association or deed documents apply. Then we write. Call me at (321) 212-7676.
Satellite Beach, 32937
Tortoise Island sits in Satellite Beach, in the 32937 zip code, on Lanternback Island, Loggerhead Island, Hawksbill Island and Tortoise. The city runs about three miles north to south on the barrier island, between Patrick Space Force Base and Indian Harbour Beach, and it is under a mile wide at most points.
The Atlantic is east and the Banana River is west, and neither is far from anywhere here. The Pineda Causeway at the north end and the Eau Gallie Causeway just south put you on the mainland in about ten minutes, which is why so many buyers work in Melbourne or at the base and still live on the beach.
Near Tortoise Island In Satellite Beach
Considering Tortoise Island?
If Tortoise Island is on your list, my partner Nichole and I are the agents to call. We work Satellite Beach every week, we know these streets, and we will tell you straight whether a property is priced right. Reach out anytime at (321) 212-7676.
Experience luxury waterfront living in the prestigious gated community of Tortoise Island in Satellite Beach, Florida. This custom riverfront estate offers spectacular pa...
- 4 Beds
- 5 Baths
- 1070139 MLS
Experience coastal luxury in the exclusive gated community of Tortoise Island. This stunning waterfront estate sits directly on the Banana River with a private dock and h...
- 5 Beds
- 5 Baths
- 1077603 MLS
Tucked behind the guarded gates of Tortoise Island, this extraordinary waterfront estate commands approximately 120-feet of prime frontage along a 17-foot deep dredged ca...
- 5 Beds
- 4 Baths
- 1083036 MLS
Seller is offering $20,000 credit towards buyers' property remodel with acceptable offer. Every home has a story, but few can claim a place in space exploration history. ...
- 4 Beds
- 4 Baths
- 1082127 MLS
A front-row seat to shimmering lake views, dramatic architecture & resort-style outdoor living awaits in this beautifully updated Tortoise Island residence, where a circu...
- 4 Beds
- 3 Baths
- 1078294 MLS
Behind the guard gate at Tortoise Island, on a quiet private lake, This home is the kind of home you can move into and simply start living in. Behind the updated finishe...
- 4 Beds
- 2 Baths
- 1084875 MLS
Located in the prestigious Tortoise Island community, this beautifully updated pool home is light, bright & designed for effortless living. An eye-catching leaded glass d...
- 4 Beds
- 3 Baths
- 1082107 MLS
