Living in Florida's Space Coast
Marsh Harbor
Marsh Harbor is a small gated pocket about three miles south of State Road 520, entered from South Courtenay Parkway by way of Inlet Way and then Marsh Harbor Avenue. The homes are close in size, 2,328 to 2,398 square feet, on lots near four tenths of an acre. Dues run $800 a year and include the gate and a community dock on the Banana River.
Marsh Harbor In Merritt Island, Florida
Everything here happens on one street. You come south on South Courtenay Parkway, turn east on Inlet Way, and then south into Marsh Harbor Avenue past the gate. The street dead ends, and several parcels sit on a cul de sac at the far end. There is no second entrance, no cut through and no reason for anyone to drive in who is not going to a specific house. That is the whole design and it is why the place feels the way it does.
The construction window runs 1993 to 2003 with the middle around 2000, and the homes are remarkably consistent in size: 2,328 to 2,398 square feet, which is a tighter band than almost any neighborhood on the island. Layouts are three and four bedroom with three baths, block and stucco on every one, shingle roofs, and soaring ceilings are a recurring feature. Most are single story, with at least one two story house carrying a winding staircase and a twenty foot entry.
Marsh Harbor Homeowner's Association, Inc. has been an active Florida nonprofit corporation since 1989. Assessments have been reported at $200 a quarter, which is $800 a year, and one owner reported the same figure billed annually. What that money buys is specific and limited: the security gate and its maintenance, and the community dock on the Banana River. There is no pool, no clubhouse and no age restriction, so nothing in the budget carries a large deferred liability.
None of the homes here are waterfront. Water access is entirely through the community dock, which is the trade this neighborhood makes: a gate, a dock and a big lot, at a price well under what private Banana River frontage costs a few streets away. All five homes are on septic tanks with public water, and on lots between 0.36 and 0.44 of an acre that works, but a septic inspection and a look at the drainfield location belong in every contract here.
Pricing has run $480,000 to $710,000 with the middle at $619,000 and closings around $577,500, at about $246 a square foot. The market here is patient. Time to contract has averaged 150 days and sellers have settled near 92 percent of their original asking price, which is a wide gap by island standards and reflects how few buyers are shopping a five house gated street at any given moment. County tax bills have run $4,279 to $7,002.
Marsh Harbor At A Glance
Marsh Harbor at a glance, including what the gate and the dock actually cost.
| Detail | What you get |
|---|---|
| Location | South Merritt Island, about 3.1 miles south of State Road 520, off South Courtenay Parkway via Inlet Way |
| Built | 1993 to 2003, most homes around 2000 |
| Home size | 2,328 to 2,398 square feet, about 2,364 typical |
| Bedrooms | 3 to 4 |
| Bathrooms | 3 |
| Lot size | 0.36 to 0.44 acre, about 0.40 typical |
| Construction | Concrete block with stucco on every home, shingle roofs, high ceilings |
| Levels | Mostly single story, with a two story home on the street |
| Association | Marsh Harbor Homeowner's Association, Inc., an active Florida nonprofit since 1989, mandatory, $200 a quarter or $800 a year |
| Association amenities | Security gate and a community dock on the Banana River |
| Gated | Yes, with a security gate at the entrance |
| Water frontage | None on the homes themselves. Water access is through the community dock |
| Pools | In ground pools on most homes, some screened |
| Garage | 2 to 3 bays |
| Utilities | Public water, septic tanks on all homes |
| Street layout | Dead end street with a cul de sac at the far end |
| Streets | Marsh Harbor Avenue, entered from Inlet Way |
| Price range | $480,000 to $710,000, around $246 per square foot |
Marsh Harbor Details
A Gate On A Street This Small
Gated communities on Merritt Island are usually large enough to spread the cost of the hardware across a hundred homes. Here the gate serves a handful, and it still only runs $800 a year, because there is no pool, no clubhouse and no landscaping contract riding alongside it in the budget.
The Dock Is The Water Access
No home in Marsh Harbor is waterfront, and the community dock on the Banana River is how residents get to the water. That structure is what keeps pricing at roughly $246 a square foot instead of the number private frontage would command a few streets over.
Houses Within Seventy Square Feet Of Each Other
The homes run 2,328 to 2,398 square feet. That is an unusually narrow band and it makes valuation simple: differences in price here come down to condition, updates, pool and lot position rather than floor plan size. Appraisals in a neighborhood like this rarely surprise anyone.
A Street That Goes Nowhere
Marsh Harbor Avenue dead ends, with cul de sac parcels at the end. Combined with the gate, that means the only vehicles on your street belong to residents and their visitors. It is the quietest configuration a neighborhood can have short of private acreage.
Real Negotiating Room
Homes have taken about 150 days to go under contract and have settled near 92 percent of their original asking price. In a five home neighborhood the buyer pool is thin at any given moment, which is frustrating if you are selling and useful if you are buying.
Solid Late Nineties Construction
Every home is block and stucco built between 1993 and 2003, past the plumbing and wiring eras that complicate older Merritt Island houses. Your inspection list is straightforward: roof age, air handler and condenser, pool surface and equipment, screen enclosure, and the septic system.
Homes For Sale In Marsh Harbor
Current availability inside Marsh Harbor. With this few homes, months can pass without anything coming up, so it is worth being on an alert rather than watching casually.
Marsh Harbor Frequently Asked Questions
Is Marsh Harbor gated?
Yes. There is a security gate at the entrance off Inlet Way, and the association budget covers it. The street beyond the gate dead ends into a cul de sac, so between the two there is effectively no traffic that does not belong there.
What do the HOA dues cost and what do they cover?
$200 a quarter, or $800 a year, paid to Marsh Harbor Homeowner's Association, Inc., an active Florida nonprofit since 1989. The money maintains the security gate and the community dock. There is no pool or clubhouse in the budget, which is why the number stays modest.
Are any homes on the water?
No. None of the homes here carry private water frontage. The community dock on the Banana River is the water access, and it is shared. If you need a lift and a private dock behind your own house, this is not the neighborhood, though it is a sensible way to keep the cost down while still having somewhere to launch.
Is the neighborhood on septic?
Yes, all homes are on septic tanks with public water. The lots are large enough to support that comfortably, but the systems are now twenty to thirty years old. Have the tank located and inspected, and pull the county permit history on any replacement or repair.
How large are the lots?
Between 0.36 and 0.44 of an acre, with about 0.40 typical. Several have few trees and open back yards, which is why the pools and covered patios here tend to be generous. It is enough room to add a shed or expand a lanai without crowding a setback.
Why do homes take so long to sell?
Time to contract has averaged about 150 days. With only a handful of homes in the neighborhood, there is rarely more than one buyer actively looking at any moment. Sellers have been settling near 92 percent of their original asking price, so patience on the buy side has been rewarded.
What are property taxes?
County bills have run roughly $4,279 to $7,002, with the middle near $6,881. Recently transferred parcels sit at the high end because a sale resets the assessed value, while long homesteaded owners sit lower. Budget from the upper figures if you are buying.
How far is it to shopping and the beach?
State Road 520 is about three miles north, which is where the retail corridor, groceries and restaurants are, and it runs east to Cocoa Beach. The Pineda Causeway to the south connects to Suntree, Viera and Interstate 95. Everyday errands are a ten minute drive.
Marsh Harbor Avenue, Merritt Island 32952
Marsh Harbor is in the 32952 ZIP code on South Merritt Island, roughly three miles south of State Road 520 along South Courtenay Parkway. The turn is east onto Inlet Way, then south into Marsh Harbor Avenue through the gate. The street runs to a dead end with a cul de sac, and the community dock sits on the Banana River side. Nothing else connects, so the neighborhood is entirely self contained.
The position is a practical one. State Road 520 to the north gives you Cocoa Beach on the east and Cocoa, US 1 and Interstate 95 on the west, roughly ten minutes to the retail corridor. The Pineda Causeway to the south reaches Suntree, Viera and Melbourne in about twenty minutes. Port Canaveral and Kennedy Space Center are farther, up Courtenay Parkway to State Road 528, closer to thirty five minutes.
Near Marsh Harbor In Merritt Island
Considering Marsh Harbor?
A neighborhood this small can go quiet for months and then produce exactly the house you wanted. My partner Nichole and I watch the street, know which homes have updated systems and which still have the original roof, and can tell you what the community dock actually accommodates. Call or text (321) 212-7676 and we will put you on the list before the next one comes up.
Executive Pool Home in Gated Community on South Merritt Island. Welcome to this 3-bedroom, 3-bath executive residence nestled on a spacious 0.4-acre lot. Boasting almost ...
- 3 Beds
- 3 Baths
- 1072780 MLS
